Hassan al-Turabi: Sudan’s democrat turned authoritarian (1932-2016)

Hassan al-Turabi: Sudan’s democrat turned authoritarian (1932-2016)


The core of the Islamist’s ideology can be difficult to pin down, but what united his many conflicting visions was the belief that they could be realised through the seizure of the state.

imageHassan al-Turabi was an influential figure in Sudan’s politics for over half a century.

On 5 March, Hassan al-Turabi, secretary general of the opposition Popular Congress Party (PCP) and long-term leader of Sudan’s Islamists, died following a short illness. Both his political career and ideology were defined by their contradictions, but al-Turabi will long remain significant as the first Islamist leader to take control of a state within the Sunni Muslim world.

Al-Turabi’s supporters have frequently presented him as a moderate thinker who sought to reconcile Islam with democracy in Sudan, but many will remember him best and bitterly as the man who orchestrated the coup that brought the current military regime of Omar al-Bashir to power in 1989.

However, al-Turabi’s close involvement in Sudanese politics began more than two decades before that pivotal moment. In fact, those who know al-Turabi as the man who aborted Sudan’s last experiment with parliamentary democracy in 1989 may find it ironic that he first rose to prominence as one of the heroes of Sudan’s democratic revolution in 1964.

One month before the outbreak of protests that led to the collapse of Sudan’s first military regime, al-Turabi had galvanised students with a speech at Khartoum University in which he declared that only liberation from military authoritarianism could guarantee the end of Sudan’s protracted civil war in the south. Few outside the Muslim Brotherhood recognised him as an Islamist at that time, but immediately after the 1964 Revolution, he established the Islamic Charter Front to campaign for a constitution based on sharia law.

Al-Turabi was a popular figure amongst the educated elites of the urban areas, and in the 1965 elections, he won more votes in Sudan’s ‘Graduate Constituencies’ than any other candidate. However, his defeat to a fellow member of the al-Turabi lineage in his home district of al-Masid in 1968 illustrated the challenges he faced in breaking the stranglehold of the existing religio-political parties – the Democratic Unionist Party and Umma Party – over the rural areas of northern Sudan where the sufi Khatmiyya and Ansar religious movements (followers of the 19th century revivalist Muhammad Ahmad al-Mahdi) were at their strongest. In 1969, al-Turabi’s former schoolmate Jafa’ar Nimeiri orchestrated a military coup, and the Islamist leader spent most of the next eight years in jail.

It seems likely that two factors from al-Turabi’s first few tumultuous years at the top of Sudanese politics contributed to his transition from democrat to authoritarian, a shift that began with his reconciliation with Nimieri in 1977. The first was the sense that rural Sudan’s ongoing attachment to the sufi and neo-Mahdist religious orders would frustrate his attempts to come to power democratically; the second was fear of the potentially terminal consequences of a protracted struggle against a military regime that had already crushed movements led by Sudan’s religiously orientated parties in 1970, 1973 and 1976.

Al-Turabi’s conflicting visions

Al-Turabi is often depicted as the architect of the ‘Islamisation’ of Sudan’s laws in 1983, although the reality is more complex. Shortly before the declaration of these laws, Nimeiri removed him from his post as Attorney-General and had two obscure lawyers prepare a draft that reversed a number of al-Turabi’s earlier promises of a liberal interpretation of sharia. Nevertheless, being dependent on Nimeiri’s favour for his own political survival, al-Turabi vociferously endorsed the laws and campaigned vigorously for them to be maintained even after Nimeiri had been overthrown.

This crucial episode highlighted al-Turabi’s trademark capacity for political and religious shapeshifting. It is perhaps telling that his most significant texts were published after he intervened in the Sudanese political arena, and his interpretations of jihad, Islamic democracy and the Islamic State were often reworked to justify political agendas he had already pursued. Like many Islamists, he employed a vision of the past to articulate his own vision of modernity, yet the vision of the future he offered was rarely a consistent one.

While al-Turabi was evidently a political animal who rejected the gradualist and ‘educationalist’ approach pursued by other Islamists in Sudan, a search for his ideological core can be a frustrating endeavour. For instance, he often presented himself as a post-colonial thinker, marketing his brand of Islamism as emancipation from cultural subjection to the West; yet his British colonial education shaped important elements of his worldview.

Following his clandestine takeover via Omar al-Bashir’s military coup in 1989, many salafi jihadists found a safe haven in Sudan, although many of the same individuals denounced al-Turabi as an unbeliever and called for his execution. He used his Popular Arab and Islamic Conference of 1991-1995 to rally radical movements all over the world against Western imperialism, but alienated many of the radical Palestinian factions, negotiated the surrender of Carlos the Jackal (who had sought protection in Khartoum) to the French, and made secret overtures to Western governments. Parties on all sides of the ‘War on Terror’ perceived al-Turabi to be treacherous.

What united al-Turabi’s many conflicting visions of the Islamic future, however, was his belief that they could be realised through the Islamic Movement’s seizure of the state. For Sudan and for al-Turabi himself, this ideological hubris was catastrophic. He had hoped that by ruling Sudan after 1989 via a secret ‘leadership bureau’ that gave its orders to the official government, he would be able to maintain his liberal image while distancing himself from the vulgar necessities that accompanied the military takeover. However, his credibility as a self-professed reformer and moderate was rapidly undermined as he was forced to deny the tortures and abuses committed by the regime he had created, the evidence of which became increasingly stark.

After his rift with al-Bashir in 1999, al-Turabi was quick to blame his erstwhile military allies for the regime’s arbitrary behaviour. But the regime in the early 1990s was so lacking in transparency that it may never be possible to judge the level of his personal responsibility, and whether his re-emergence as a champion of democracy in the late 1990s was part of his long-term strategy or rather a knee-jerk response brought about by conflict with ambitious junior colleagues in the Islamic Movement keen to usurp him.

In the years following his split with al-Bashir, al-Turabi was imprisoned five times and even called on the president to surrender himself to the International Criminal Court to face charges of genocide. Many of the Islamists hailing from Sudan’s marginalised regions, particularly Darfur, sided with al-Turabi after the split, and the government accused him of backing the rebel Justice and Equality Movement in Darfur.

Nevertheless, it seems that al-Turabi himself may have been instrumental in persuading the Darfuri Islamists who joined his PCP party to fight a civil as opposed to military struggle against the regime, fearing that an intensification of the Darfur conflict might lead to the breakup of the country.

After al-Turabi

The events that follow al-Turabi’s death will probably reveal the extent to which the rift in the Islamic Movement was determined by the animosity between himself and al-Bashir. Without the symbolic al-Turabi at its helm, many elements within the Popular Congress Party may complete the process of reintegration into al-Bashir’s National Congress Party that appeared to have begun in 2015. But without al-Turabi’s restraining influence, other Darfuri Islamists might also be persuaded to abandon the arena of civil politics in Khartoum and join rebel movements fighting the political centre.

[See: Sudan’s Islamist Resurrection: al-Turabi and the Successor Regime]

However, to anticipate the immediate eclipse of Islamism in Sudan on account of al-Turabi’s passing would be to overstate the agency of the man. Al-Turabi did not invent Islamism in Sudan – many of his followers were as influenced by globally famous Islamist ideologues such as Abu’l Ala Mawdudi, Sayyid Qutb and Hasan al-Banna as they were by al-Turabi himself.

His prominence came from his charismatic personality and his ability to mediate between a number of competing ideological and religious trends, including Salafism, Sufism, Qutbism and reformism. When he left the government in 1999, the regime did not so much abandon ideology so much as complete what Olivier Roy characterised in 1994 as the transition from Islamism to neo-fundamentalism, from an ideology that emphasises social and political revolution to one more concerned with regulating social mores.

The increasing visibility of Sudan’s Public Order Police is evidence of this. Nevertheless, al-Turabi himself continued to advocate a revolutionary brand of Islamism after 1999, and his party retained a significant following among student milieus in Sudan. If the regime fails to reintegrate al-Turabi’s former followers into the Islamic Movement, this ideology may still represent the most significant threat it faces.

 

Advertisements

Leave a comment

No comments yet.

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  • Daily Alert News

  • THE GARISSA GENOCIDE AND THE PLIGHT OF KENYAN SOMALIS SINCE “INDEPENDENCE”.

  • Political Analyst & Expert in East Africa politics Moment History Society

  • Xisbiga Xuriyadda

  • Taariikh nololeedkii Imaam Axmad Gurey

  • taariikhda sheekh xasan barsane oo kooban

  • Reflections on the life and learning of Prof. Said Samatar

    Professor Said Samatar who died February 24, 2015

  • Recent Posts

  • Truth to Power

  • Wall Truth

  • RSS osservatore romano – Google News

    • This RSS feed URL is deprecated December 16, 2017
      This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at https://news.google.com/news
    • VATICANO/ Qual è il vantaggio di una "newsroom" rispetto all ... - Il Sussidiario.net December 15, 2017
      Il Sussidiario.netVATICANO/ Qual è il vantaggio di una "newsroom" rispetto all ...Il Sussidiario.netIl cambiamento nel settore media si sta facendo più accelerato e intenso ovunque. Anche in Vaticano. Dove la parola d'ordine è razionalizzare.FarodiRoma Biotestamento. L'Osservatore Romano è pacato: "legge ...Farodiroma (Comunicati Sta […]
    • Media vaticani, Viganò: una redazione unica per tutti i canali - La ... - La Stampa December 13, 2017
      La StampaMedia vaticani, Viganò: una redazione unica per tutti i canali - La ...La StampaTra pochi giorni il lancio in versione “beta” del portale www.vaticannews.va. Da gennaio l'accorpamento de L'Osservatore Romano. «Il Papa è d'accordo»Mons. Viganò: «Social, tv, giornale e radio: così cambiano i media ...Corriere della SeraEcco come saranno […]
    • Perché secondo l'Osservatore Romano sul fine vita il Papa innova - Formiche.net November 18, 2017
      Formiche.netPerché secondo l'Osservatore Romano sul fine vita il Papa innovaFormiche.netAffannarsi a tener bordone alle strumentalizzazioni politiche spremute dalle parole che Papa Francesco ha consegnato al convegno ospitato in Vaticano sul fine-vita? Il netto del discorso di Jorge Mario Bergoglio va accolto per quello che è: non una ...
    • Società: card. Bassetti su L'Osservatore Romano, disoccupazione ... - Servizio Informazione Religiosa December 7, 2017
      Società: card. Bassetti su L'Osservatore Romano, disoccupazione ...Servizio Informazione ReligiosaNel “vissuto quotidiano dell'Italia” sono presenti diverse forme di povertà, “ma sono almeno tre le emergenze che fanno suonare un campanello di allarme”. Lo scrive il card. Gualtiero Bassetti, arcivescovo di Perugia–Città della Pieve e presidente ...a […]
    • Papa Francesco: Vian (“L'Osservatore Romano”), “l'importante è che ... - Servizio Informazione Religiosa December 7, 2017
      Servizio Informazione ReligiosaPapa Francesco: Vian (“L'Osservatore Romano”), “l'importante è che ...Servizio Informazione Religiosa“L'importante è che 'il messaggio arrivi'”: “La prima risposta del Papa nella conversazione con i giornalisti, consueta durante il volo di ritorno nei viaggi internazionali, va ben oltre la questione dei […]
    • L'Osservatore Romano: dedicato al potere simbolico del corpo ... - Servizio Informazione Religiosa December 1, 2017
      L'Osservatore Romano: dedicato al potere simbolico del corpo ...Servizio Informazione Religiosa“Donne Chiesa Mondo”, il mensile de “L'Osservatore Romano”, dedica il numero di dicembre a “Il potere simbolico del corpo delle donne”. In copertina la celebre immagine della donna che in Louisiana, durante gli scontri fra afroamericani e polizia, sola .. […]
    • Siria, l'incontro Assad-Putin visto dall'Osservatore Romano - Formiche.net November 22, 2017
      Formiche.netSiria, l'incontro Assad-Putin visto dall'Osservatore RomanoFormiche.netIn Siria le operazioni militari contro i terroristi si stanno avvicinando alla fine ed “è arrivato il momento di lavorare per una soluzione politica della crisi”. È quanto ha dichiarato ieri il capo di stato russo Vladimir Putin rivolgendosi al ...altro »
    • Bestemmia in tv: L'Osservatore Romano contro la Rai - Taranto in Diretta (Blog) December 15, 2017
      Bestemmia in tv: L'Osservatore Romano contro la RaiTaranto in Diretta (Blog)“L'Osservatore Romano”, il giornale del Vaticano, si scaglia contro la Tv di Stato con un titolo violento: «Fuori controllo». «La televisione, pubblica o privata che sia, per acquisire una dimensione social a tutti i costi rischia di divenire uno ...
    • Frate Emiliano e la frase del Papa: “Non sparlate degli altri” - Rete8 December 16, 2017
      Rete8Frate Emiliano e la frase del Papa: “Non sparlate degli altri”Rete8Frate Emiliano Antenucci incontra il Papa e gli dona una copia dell'Icona della Vergine del Silenzio. Il Pontefice vi scrive dietro: “Non sparlate degli altri” e la pone nel Palazzo Apostolico. Frate Emiliano è da un anno e mezzo circa guardiano del ...
    • Anche il Vaticano punta sulla trasformazione digitale - 01Net December 15, 2017
      01NetAnche il Vaticano punta sulla trasformazione digitale01NetDal primo gennaio il percorso si completerà con l'accorpamento dell'Osservatore Romano, del Servizio Fotografico e della Tipografia Vaticana. La diffusione dei contenuti avviene secondo un approccio complementare ai media. Questo approccio è stato ...I mass media del Papa dal 31 dicembr […]
  • RSS avvenire – Google News

    • This RSS feed URL is deprecated December 16, 2017
      This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at https://news.google.com/news
    • La vicenda. Abusi, la Curia di Milano: false ricostruzioni su un caso ... - Avvenire.it December 15, 2017
      Avvenire.itLa vicenda. Abusi, la Curia di Milano: false ricostruzioni su un caso ...Avvenire.itReplica a un articolo che chiama in causa l'attuale arcivescovo Delpini e il vescovo Tremolada. "Nessuna copertura, ma intervento immediato". Vittima un quindicenne. Il prete è sotto processo. L'ingresso dell'arcivescovado di Milano in piaz […]
    • Biotestamento, ecco cosa prevede la nuova legge. E cosa non va - Avvenire.it December 15, 2017
      Avvenire.itBiotestamento, ecco cosa prevede la nuova legge. E cosa non vaAvvenire.itOgni persona maggiorenne in previsione di una futura malattia che la renda incapace di autodeterminarsi può, attraverso le Dat, le disposizioni anticipate di trattamento, esprimere le proprie preferenze sui trattamenti sanitari, accettare o rifiutare ...altro »
    • Australia: pedofilia tragedia nazionale. Le richieste alla Chiesa - Avvenire.it December 15, 2017
      Avvenire.itAustralia: pedofilia tragedia nazionale. Le richieste alla ChiesaAvvenire.itLa Commissione d'inchiesta che dal 2012 indaga su decine di migliaia di casi: il 60% delle vittime in ambito religioso. «Si rivedano le regole sul celibato»Malcolm Turnbull - WikipediaWikipediaIl Papa: “Non firmerò mai la grazia ai pedofili”In Terristutte le notizie ( […]
    • Televisione. «Sarà Sanremo», i giovani in gara per un posto al ... - Avvenire.it December 15, 2017
      Avvenire.itTelevisione. «Sarà Sanremo», i giovani in gara per un posto al ...Avvenire.itSedici giovani si sfideranno in diretta da Villa Ormond, ma solo sei di loro avranno la possibilità di esibirsi sul palcoscenico del Teatro Ariston. Il boom di “X Factor” con la vittoria di Licitra. Il palco dell'Ariston nell'edizione di Sanremo 2017 ...altro » […]
    • Il killer di Budrio. Spari e 3 morti: preso in Spagna Igor «il russo» - Avvenire.it December 15, 2017
      Avvenire.itIl killer di Budrio. Spari e 3 morti: preso in Spagna Igor «il russo»Avvenire.itL'uomo ha ingaggiato un conflitto a fuoco con la Guardia Civil prima d'essere arrestato. In Italia aveva già commesso due omicidi. Spari e 3 morti: preso in Spagna Igor «il russo». Ha sparato e lottato fino alla fine Igor “il russo”, il killer di ...altro » […]
    • Indonesia. Terremoto a Giava. «Crolli e vittime» - Avvenire.it December 15, 2017
      Avvenire.itIndonesia. Terremoto a Giava. «Crolli e vittime»Avvenire.itLa magnitudo è stata di 6.5 e la scossa è stata sentita per 20 secondi anche nella capitale Giacarta. Allerta tsunami, poi revocata. Una casa gravemente danneggiata dalla scossa sismica (Ansa). La forte scossa di terremoto di magnitudo 6.5 registrata ...altro »
    • Il viaggio / 6. A Beirut una sartoria per ricucire le esistenze delle ... - Avvenire.it December 15, 2017
      Avvenire.itIl viaggio / 6. A Beirut una sartoria per ricucire le esistenze delle ...Avvenire.itNel vecchio palazzo a Sad el-Baouchriyé, nord di Beirut, anche Sara, 64 anni, sposta lenta gli scatoloni pieni di vestiti. Con lei altre compagne di lavoro organizzano quello che alla Boutique sociale di Arc en ciel, la più importante Ong libanese ...altro »
    • No, non è un bel giorno. La legge sulle Dat, i soldati in Niger - Avvenire.it December 15, 2017
      Avvenire.itNo, non è un bel giorno. La legge sulle Dat, i soldati in NigerAvvenire.itPerché è del tutto chiaro che esse intendono raddoppiare la barriera frettolosamente e imperfettamente costruita nel Mediterraneo di fronte alla Tripolitania e alla Cirenaica per sigillare le violenze e le sopraffazioni dei rinchiusi nei piccoli e ...altro »
    • Editoria cattolica, guai e gioie: Famiglia Cristiana digiuna, Avvenire ... - Affaritaliani.it December 15, 2017
      Affaritaliani.itEditoria cattolica, guai e gioie: Famiglia Cristiana digiuna, Avvenire ...Affaritaliani.itPer Famiglia Cristiana i tempi d'oro sono finiti. In una crisi generalizzata, l'unico giornale cattolico che dia buoni risultati, per ora, è Avvenire. I numeri.altro »
    • «Sulle Dat faremo obiezione di coscienza» - Avvenire - Avvenire.it December 15, 2017
      Avvenire.it«Sulle Dat faremo obiezione di coscienza» - AvvenireAvvenire.itIl direttore dell'Ufficio nazionale di pastorale della salute: valutazione non positiva. Nasceranno contenziosi, si lascia morire chi soffre. Una norma sul fine vita poteva essere utile, ma non questa.altro »